Rent control may help existing tenants, but it does not solve the broader problem of housing affordability. This is not a particularly disputed contention among economists. You know how virtually all scientists will tell you climate change is real? Yeah, so there’s a similar consensus among economists about the negative effects of rent control on housing supply. In one survey, 93.5% of economists agreed that rent ceilings reduce the quantity and quality of available housing.
The reason rent control gets proposed is because it seems like it would work: Want rents to stop going up? Pass a law that says that they can’t!
So why doesn’t that work? It’s because the problem of housing affordability is one of supply and demand. When too many people want to live in one place, rents and housing prices go up because there is inadequate supply of housing to meet the market demand. Rent control does not change this. It doesn’t create another apartment. It simply makes rent-controlled apartments more attractive to renters while doing nothing to increase the number available. Indeed, by holding rents below market rates, it can increase competition for the very apartments that are already in short supply. Was low demand the problem in the first place? It was not.
On the flip side, rent control changes the math for developers and landlords. A developer has to put in millions (either self-funded or via loan) and depending on how the rent control law is structured, the math no longer maths. Landlords who might have rented a property might pull it from the market or put it up for sale, either reducing rental housing supply or, at best, keeping the supply equal. Nothing about rent control directly increases housing supply; indeed, it sends a strong signal to developers and landlords: Think twice before building or renting here.
And this isn’t just economic theory. A 2019 study by Stanford economists examined San Francisco’s expansion of rent control and found that affected landlords reduced rental housing supply by approximately 15%, in part by converting rental properties or selling them to owner-occupants. The researchers also found that the resulting reduction in rental supply contributed to higher market rents across the city. In other words, a policy intended to make housing more affordable actually helped make housing more expensive for people outside the rent-controlled units.
Over time the results can be damaging. For example, New York City, where about half the rental units are rent regulated, reportedly had approximately 57,000 vacant rent-stabilized apartments in 2025. Landlords argue that restrictions on recovering renovation costs have made some of these units uneconomical to repair and re-rent. Exactly how many are vacant for that reason is disputed, but the underlying economic incentive is straightforward: If the cost of making an apartment rentable exceeds the financial return, the owner has little incentive to make the investment.
The fix is simple in principle: Build more housing. In Oregon that’s made tricky by the Urban Growth Boundary (UGB), a line that circles most cities in the state and generally prevents urban development outside it. Even now, you can travel not even 5 minutes outside of Salem and find acres of land that appears suitable for housing but isn’t available for ordinary urban development.
This is not an argument against the UGB. Oregon established its statewide land-use planning system under Gov. Tom McCall in the 1970s, and UGBs have helped preserve farmland and restrain urban sprawl. But we have to also recognize that restricting the geographic area available for urban development can constrain housing supply and increase land costs, particularly when cities fail to make sufficient land available for development within their boundaries.
And the UGB isn’t the only obstacle. Zoning restrictions, infrastructure costs, permitting delays, and other development requirements can make it difficult or uneconomical to build housing even on land already inside the UGB. Salem, for example, has concluded that it has sufficient land within its existing boundary to accommodate projected housing needs. The challenge is making it economically and practically feasible to build the housing we need on that land.
That’s perhaps good news for me as a homeowner as it elevates the value of my property, but it’s less good for my kids who don’t own a home and now have a harder time affording one.
Expanding the UGB or not is a policy choice. So are allowing greater housing density, reducing regulatory barriers, and investing in infrastructure to support new development. And we need to recognize that home ownership and high home values sit in tension with housing affordability. That’s a bit of a political minefield, to be sure.
But if we’re not going to expand the UGB or make it substantially easier to build more housing within existing boundaries, then Oregon will continue to have constrained housing supply. Rent control doesn’t solve for that. Yes, it can protect tenants who already have apartments, but those benefits come at a cost to everyone else. Rent control discourages investment in rental housing, reduces the supply of available rentals, and puts upward pressure on rents in the unregulated market. These are not merely theoretical concerns; they’re consequences documented by decades of economic research. There’s a reason economists overwhelmingly oppose rent control as a solution to housing affordability: It attempts to solve a shortage by discouraging the very activity necessary to eliminate it—providing more housing.
We cannot regulate our way out of a housing shortage. We have to build our way out.